by Josh
I see a common theme in the email and comments I receive, and in forums where people who are new to project management are active.
A good chunk of you are asking about tools.
project manager tools - by Svadilfari via Flickr
Tools, tools, tools. MS Project. Primavera. Wrike. Basecamp. So many others big and small. There’s a lot of money and attention in the “project manager tools” market. I am contacted nearly once a week by some company who wants me to do a review of their new wiz-bang software that slices, dices, and makes julienne fries. You’ll notice however that I do not normally take them up on their offers.
It’s not that I think their products are crap. I’m sure they are probably very good. Here’s the thing…
Project Managers Focus Too Much On Tools
This is especially true for new project managers. If you’ve never drawn a network diagram on a sheet of paper and done a forwards and backwards pass to determine your critical path and slack, STOP EVERYTHING! Go do it for a small sample project. I can personally recommend the text I learned it from, “Project Management – The Managerial Process“. See Chapter 6 in particular.
Tools Don’t Manage Projects. You Do.
Don’t get me wrong. I love tools too. They can be very helpful and allow analysis or rigor that just would not be feasible otherwise. In fact it is very common for me to create my own tools that are customized to my own projects. I’m a big believer in solid up-front effort to realize ongoing gains in productivity going forward.
I can only do this because I took the time and put in the effort to understand the concepts first.
So, as I always do in email and in forums where the topic is brought up, I urge you who are starting out in project management to seek an understanding of the concepts for formal project management first.
Then you can become a tool head.
26 Comments
Glen B. Alleman July 18 2009 12:43 pm
Paul,
It might be that after 40 or so years since your high school days, things may have changed.
One of primary clients (a $44B aerospace firm) includes tools skills side by side with the principles and procsses of PP&C. Without the in depth understanding of how the corporate tools work (cost, schedule, contractor, risk) on day one, the understanding of how to "manage" is a two step procecss not a one step process.
The integrated "process, people, and tools" approach to training of PP&C, Control Account Managers, Program Managers, and Technical Leads has been shown to produce superior results. The students gain understanding of both "why" and "how" to manage.
Constance SticklerJuly 15, 2009 8:12 am
“Tools Don’t Manage Projects. You Do.”
That’s so right! Since almost 10 years I work as a project manager; right now I’m even the product manager of a project management software.
I met a lot of different methods, tools and people through this 10 years. And regardless if it’s a very complex or simple method or tool – it’s always the human beings who make it work… or not.
Projects may even be successful without tools – if the team contains the right people: organised, experienced, good social skills, reliable, on time, etc. The more of these parameters are in place the less contracts, planning, etc. is needed.
Glen B. AllemanJuly 15, 2009 8:21 am
Josh,
You have a point about the focus on tools. Tools are necessary but not sifficient for success. But without the “proper” tools we can’t address the core issues with project failure:
1. Inattention to budgetary responsibilities
2. Work authorization not always followed
3. Budget and data reconciliation issues
4. Lack of an integrated management system
5. Baseline fluctuations & frequent replanning
6. Current period and retroactive changes Improper use of management reserve
7. Earned Value techniques not reflecting actual accomplishments
8. Untimely and unrealistic Latest Revised Estimates (LRE)
9. Progress not monitored in a regular and consistent manner
10. Lack of vertical and horizontal traceability (critical path)
11. Not capturing and using cost and schedule data for corrective action
12. Lack of predictive variance analysis
13. Lack of internal surveillance and controls
Managerial actions not demonstrated using Earned Value
It is unlikey the PM would be able to deal with these issues in the absence of tools.
So a bigger question seems to be “what processes are needed for successful project?” That seems to me to be the bigger issue with new PM’s is knowing what they need in terms of step-by-step actions and how to build up a collection of processes to improve their chances of success.
I’ve seen new PM’s be clueless about burn rates, late starts mean late finishes, unaccounted for rework, measures of completion, and others.
Avinash Palve July 15 2009 23:06 pm
Glen,
I'm completely agree with you. Tools are very helpful in proper decision making.
By the way decisions have to be made by PM, tools help with early warnings where to go.
Josh Nankivel July 18 2009 13:08 pm
Exactly Glen. Tools can help address all of the items you listed. I am stressing that if someone is given a tool designed to address one of those items, but has no foundational knowledge on the topic, they can not utilize the potential of the tool. They won't notice red flags or be able to adapt the tool for their own situation.
Karine SimardJuly 15, 2009 8:36 am
Josh, I completely agree with you.
Project management is about getting people to deliver. The best teams with the worst tools will succeed. And the worst teams with the best tools will fail.
While we DO need tools, it’s way more important to build an effective and functional team.
Glen B. Alleman July 18 2009 12:32 pm
On anything but a trival project, the best team with the worst tools will have little visibilty into what "done" looks, how they are making progress toward "done," and what impediments there are the way to done..
Tools will not help the worst teams, beacuse the worst teams won't be able to recognize what the tools tell them.
It's not a matter of "either or" both "good" teams and and "good" tools are needed for success.
Josh Nankivel July 18 2009 13:05 pm
Karine, I'm not talking about the quality of project teams here. Very important, but not in scope for this post.
I'm saying that diving into tools without understanding the fundamentals and concepts those tools use is folly.
For example, learning how to use MS Project is not a good starting point for someone who is completely new to project management. I urge them to understand the strategy and process and the "why" first before diving into a specific tool.
AceProjectNow (AceProject)July 15, 2009 8:43 am
Tool-obsessed PMs: focus on the people (I commented) [link to post] (via @pmstudent)
projectshrink (Bas de Baar)July 15, 2009 10:33 am
Shared: Project Manager Tools Crazy [link to post]
PhoenixHawk (Sebastian PR Gingter)July 15, 2009 10:34 am
So true. And also for building software: RT @ProjectShrink: Shared: Project Manager Tools Crazy [link to post]
Travis AndersonJuly 15, 2009 10:18 pm
Josh,
I found that the ILL Microsoft Project Orange Belt training (Dynamic Scheduling with Microsoft Project 2003) was absolutely remarkable. This is a book I refer back to often. Even thought I am a huge fan of Primavera as a tool vs. MSP, this book is loaded with fundamentals for managing a dynamic schedule. Everybody working on projects should have a copy available.
Also, the Primavera 101 & 102 training is highly recommended. The trainers are very knowledgeable about many concepts, methodologies, and practical applications. Primavera built P6.2 with these concepts in mind to help take failure out of projects.
maventraining (Maven Training)July 16, 2009 2:31 am
@pmstudent – Sharing: tools, tools, tools – why so many in PM?
[link to post]
ejlyJuly 16, 2009 7:14 am
Amen, preacher. Tools should enable you as a PM to do what you need to do and not be an end in and of themselves.
@Travis – I have also found the IIL training in general to be a good value, though I haven’t taken the one you mention.
severa_psa (Tiina R)July 16, 2009 7:33 am
RT @pmstudent: #PMOT Comment on Project Manager Tools Crazy by maventraining (Maven Training): Twitter Comment .. [link to post]
trchandler (Todd Chandler)July 19, 2009 5:54 pm
@pmstudent enjoyed your post on Project Manager Tools Crazy [link to post]
Leave A Comment
Posting your comment...
Dr. Paul D. GiammalvoJuly 15, 2009 6:33 am
Well stated, Josh!!
Your explanation brings to mind a maxim frequently quoted by my old high school trade school teacher…..
He used to say “A fool with a tool is still a fool- only a more dangerous one.” He would not allow freshmen and sophomores to even touch a power tool until they could first demonstrate a mastery using hand tools.
And his words of wisdom ring true to me in today’s world of project management. We have become so reliant on “software solutions” that we have forgotten that software is NOT a solution. Only people can be solutions……
Software is only a tool, and as we know, a fool with a tool…….
BR,
Dr. PDG, Singapore
http://www.getpmcertified.com