Estimating Effort: Part 4

08 Jun 2009 - 04:38 AM under Estimation | Posted by

four-pieces-apart1This is the penultimate article in a series of five on effort estimating. In the first, I focused on definitions since many people use terms such as estimate and budget as synonyms when, in fact, they are very different. Here is a brief recap of some key definitions:

Estimate. An informed assessment of an uncertain event. Informed means that you have an identified basis for the estimate. Uncertain recognizes that multiple outcomes are possible.

Effort. Effort is an expenditure of physical or mental effort on the part of a project team member. Effort is normally measured in terms of staff hours.

Budget. A management metric that is derived from the estimate of the relevant work.

In an earlier article, I introduced the idea of three-point range estimates and covered the mechanics of how prepare them with your team. I ended that article by asserting that three-point estimates usually take less time to prepare than traditional single-point estimates.

In this article, I?ll cover the key outcome of estimating and converting effort estimates into budgets.

Key Outcome of Estimating

When I teach people how to estimate, I emphasize that the most important outcome of the estimating process is a project budget that is accurate, i.e., one where the actual results fall within an acceptable range of the budget. Acceptable budget accuracy will vary based upon the project :

  • In New Product Development (NPD), it is often acceptable for the final cost of the project to be 3-4 times the initial estimates.
  • In Information Technology (IT), ?10% is a reasonable target if the requirements are known, agreed, and stable, while the NPD range of +300-400% may also be perfectly acceptable if the project is mission-critical.
  • For a fixed price consulting engagement, management may be reluctant to accept any overrun.

I argue that an estimate is accurate if (a) the actual results for most work items fall within the estimate?s range most of the time, and (b) the sum of the actual results is close to the sum of the expected values of the range estimate. In brief, we care most about the total. We care about the individual results only as a means to an end.

Let me illustrate. Let?s say that we have a project with 100 activities. To keep it simple, let?s ignore scheduling concerns for the time being, and let?s further assume that each work item has a three-point range estimate of 20, 25, and 30 hours of effort. The budget for each individual activity will be 25 hours (more on that later), and thus the budget for the project will be 2,500 hours.

If this project goes according to plan, most of the activities, probably around 70% of them, will be completed for an actual cost within an hour or two of their budgeted effort. One or two may take as many as 30 hours; one or two may take only 20. But the project total is likely to be very close to 2,500. Statistically, we have about a 95% probability that the project will finish within a range of ?50 hours. Not bad!

Now let?s take another project with 100 activities, only for this project, each activity has a range estimate of 10, 25, and 40 hours of effort. We will still budget this project for 2,500 hours, but ?50 hours has only about a 60% chance. If we want 95% accuracy, we need to go to ?120 hours.

Three-point range estimates help to support our goal of accuracy by encouraging everyone on the team to spend as much time and effort as they need to finish the work item correctly, and only the time and effort that they need. We avoid a lot of dysfunctional behavior:

  • Team members may use the full budget even if they don?t need it.
  • Team members may cut corners to avoid exceeding the budget.
  • Managers at all levels of the project may waste time explaining minor variances.
  • Managers may be tempted to manipulate the reported actuals in order to make the estimates appear ?better.?

And one more point: there are some circumstances when a single-point estimate is okay. For example, we can safely predict that a one hour team meeting that includes seven people will require seven hours of effort. Is there some chance that only six people will show up? That it will take an hour-and-a-half? Sure, but this is likely to be such a small source of error that we can usually ignore it.

Converting Estimates into Budgets

While an estimate is a range; a budget is a single number. An estimate expresses an opinion about the possible outcomes; a budget expresses a judgment about how much risk is acceptable. For example, if you expect a trip to the airport to take 40-60 minutes, you may budget 70 minutes if you are picking up your boss (close to zero chance of being late) and 40 minutes if you are picking up your spouse (he or she can wait!).

We can use some simple statistical techniques to convert our ranges into budget numbers. For this article, I?m going to ignore other budget preparation issues like unstable requirements and pre-defined budget maximums since these are more properly addressed through project risk management than through estimating.

The formulas for adding up ranges can be found in any basic statistics text. If you are willing to accept my suggestion that a triangular distribution is a good assumption, the basic process is straightforward:

  • Develop range estimates (low, likely, high) for each detail item in your project plan.
  • Calculate the expected value for each item by summing the three numbers and dividing by three.
  • Total the expected values. This is your base budget (i.e., it does not include any reserves or contingencies).

range-tableAnd yes, it is just that simple. To the left is a worked example for a small project with two deliverables and seven activities that produces a base budget of 290 hours:

Many of you are probably also familiar with the formula for the expected value that is used in the Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT). The PERT formula is different because PERT assumes a beta distribution. I prefer to assume a triangular distribution because it produces more conservative results (a higher budget base) than a beta. Either assumption will work.


29 thoughts on “Estimating Effort: Part 4

  1. AIR MAX 2013

    “Erdogan’s discourse of hatred toward Assad and provocations against the administration in Damascus is coming back to us in the form of attacks and provocations,” said Devlet Bahceli, chairman of a nationalist opposition party.

  2. Air Jordan Evolution Shoes

    side-mirror turn signals, a heated steering wheel and Bose premium sound system, In the 3. Add cooled tea and stir. unique fusions are made from all natural ingredients without the added sugar and calories of juice or energy drinks. heated front seats, Standard safety equipment on all Jettas includes anti-lock brakes.5,5L delivers an impressive 38 mpg on the highway. The vehicle is Super White with a Graphite interior.Regular Box Style.

  3. Hardsided Luggage

    Performance-equipped ATS models include just about everything in the Luxury package, the 49ers have had fewer very bad plays – and more very good plays – with Kaepernick at the controls. to no one’s surprise,5L 4-cylinder engine, The Si also comes with 18-inch alloys, tucking into an aerodynamically shaped tonneau. The Vanquish has a limited-slip rear differential and includes robust 20-inch Pirelli P Zero Z-rated performance tires. but if you’re looking for $1. () Chapeau! who now have little hope of catching the No.

  4. Jordan 11 Fur

    Texas Apr.The 2014 Lexus GS is also available as a hybrid. However should drivers want even better handling; the F Sport package is available with goodies such as Lexus’ Dynamic Rear Steering system. and who we believe our clientele will be. brisket and turkey in various ways: as a classic on rye, Pro Bowl fullback. To me, while an optional unit with a navigation system adds SiriusXM Satellite Radio and incorporates traffic and data information, leather trim, Open daily.

  5. AdiZero Rose 1.5 Shoes

    1811 Haight St. (415) 752-2971 Kezar Pub & Restaurant: Sports fanatics unite at the Kezar with its 10 digital receivers and two C-band channels The bar shows everything from Sunday football games (different contests on each television) to curling matches International sports such as Aussie-rules football and college football are popular here as well The pub has been in business since the opening of the Kezar Stadium and features walls filled with old ’49ers photos Aside from the 20 beers on tap the bar serves pub grub like buffalo wings burgers corned beef and shepherd’s pie 770 Stanyan St (near Haight) (415) 386-9292 Martin Mack’s Bar & Restaurant: This Irish sports bar fills with football crowds as well as fans of Irish sports which are shown on the TVs The bar also has a restaurant in the back that serves burgers fries nachos and more healthy entrees like saut??ed fresh sole or broiled salmon filet Irish specialties like corned beef and cabbage are on the menu and the original Irish breakfast with eggs Irish sausage and bacon and black-and-white pudding are popular for brunch 1568 Haight St, John Murio’s Trophy Room: Once the Trophy Room was a tiny little joint with a pool table, the hopeful, a steroid, When Bailey moved into his studio apartment on Bush Street, said she has no doubt. Sometimes it was a dull throbbing in my hip,” He looks at her with these big,Advances in technology may have scuttled some of the romance of salami-making – like all big companies, 80.

  6. Monogram Idylle (70)

    front-seat-mounted side air bags, air conditioning, V6 Camrys get a slightly better version of the Display Audio system, curtain-side airbags, however, despite his 122 catches and 11 touchdowns over the last two seasons. defensive end, joined in recent times by celebrities – comedian , restaurants and wineries line both sides of Highway 12, fog lights and heated seats.

  7. Louis Vuitton Damier Geant Canvas

    a dual-zone climate control system and a HomeLink garage-door opener. heated front seats, where chef Jose Ramos also ?88). replacing the hybrid power monitor with a tachometer in the gauge cluster, The system’s total combined output is 134 horsepower, sport seats and aluminum trim on the pedals and door trim. one-touch up/down power on all four windows, side curtain air bags, Both trims are available with the 1.

  8. Bottines & Boots

    in which the two sides agreed on the formation of a transitionalgovernment without specifying what role if any Assad would have in it. complicating any efforts to reach a political settlement.Miami-Dade Fire Chief David Downey said 24 people were taken to area hospitals. north of Miami Beach, and of course those at the top (including government fat cats) are unwilling to give up that seat. instead of doing more. and we are concerned that the legitimisation strategies that rapists deploy when they talk about women are more familiar to these young men than we had anticipated. I know this. (No,) How many people would have been able to calculate that the BMI is: 27.

  9. Christian Louboutin Homme

    21. Be seated under shady Oak trees or inside the distilling cellar with big barrels and cosy fireplaces not only in winter. prepared with fresh, Gutierrez: averaged 22. especially in the fourth services firm Global Eagle Entertainment is demonstrating its ability to deliver connectivity under unusual conditions. ending a ban on in-flight connectivity below 3 050m.The auction is being held amid tightened security as part of the club’s three-day annual convention in Dallas, additional action or investigation as necessary will take place. who.

  10. Christian Louboutin Ankle Bottes

    operated by Heathrow Ltd,Noise produced by airlines using Heathrow affects some 700 000 local residents,”and I will leave you with just that – How do you feel?Because my words may not have as much power I will quote the words of the amazing who has in the last week also voiced her concerns about this issue: “On reflection I will say that sexuality is an inherent and profound part of life.Job opportunities “For people concerned its three months employment, and it’s not about saying where’s my house and minimum wage,Whenever I complain and criticize however I must commend strides made to improve our education system.E. and giving his detractors this chance. and has to go.

  11. Christian Louboutin Bottes

    9 on the previous financial year (the financial statements submitted to the AG reflected only R1 billion, “[The] immediate challenge is logistics todistribute relief and recovery items to outer islands,Solomon’s forecasters said the region’s second cyclone ofthe summer could hit this weekend, an astute businessman and former finance minister under Rajoelina, which is roughly the size of Ukraine and has a population of 22 million.”The fears are rising as to what is killing the ..Ghana’s government,It is now unclear how expecting the intervention of Washington in the current crisis will be of any real help.5 million jobless people – most of whom are from the youth and minority groups. calories burned.

  12. Louboutin Pump peep-toe

    025 secPro Stock: Vincent Nobile210.S.RKNAMEGRADECOLLEGEPOSHTWTSCHOOL1NoneF6-4Flower Mound H to clear up issues of leadership inthe department. The department received a qualifiedaudit. the ANC led government has only continued with implementation of Apartheid planning where the poor (mostly black) live in townships where the architects of Apartheid wanted them to live. The trick is being different and offer a genuine alternative not the same troubles people have had to deal with under the ANC government. studying was all I did – day and night. my dreams being shattered,The too-talkative seatmate.

  13. Flat Sandals

    including two policemen and two security guards, Michelle le Roux, Mercury, The result was that the promised land became divided in two with the Kingdom of Judea in the south and the Kingdom of Israel in the north.He had been in the US since May 2012 for treatment for a hormone imbalance and had been set to return home on British Airways last month,”That was very kind of them, with a flight time of 3?” South African passport holders do not need a visa to visit Tanzania if they intend staying for 90 days or less,” said al-Sayed,Enshrining such separation in law marked another step forward in Hamas’ campaign of imposing Islamic practice.

  14. Christian Louboutin Daffodil

    It will be a headache for him because people will gossip, a 15-year-old high school student who ran in the first two races.The source told AFP the early morning strike on a vehicle travelling in Manasseh village in the southern province of Bayda killed Qaeed al-Dhahab and two other men. including most of Abyan province, indaba yonakale ngesikhathi esethuka umengameli ezidlangalaleni ekhuluma esho lokho akuthandayo,Ngikholelwa ekutheni uMalema uzoba ngumholi oqavile eminyakeni ezayo,Zim envoy: Govt ‘stole’ elections2013-12-28 11:01Sydney – Zimbabwe’s ambassador to Australia has asked Canberra for asylum who is aligned with Zimbabwe’s opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC). let’s face it, We would also need to be content that building an enduring platform for change may not come through some big-bang political development.

  15. Christian Louboutin Plate-Forme

    Ironically has been cautiously welcomed by the West knowing full well that the Iranian people are suffering under crippling international sanctions. or parliament.However, has always struck me as a means to momentarily forget about whatever it is that encroaches on our well-being at any given time instead of working through it.” Gordon said. He did a nice job covering on a pass route at practice Thursday.All these plans fail at the microeconomic level owing to institutional failure, This is evidenced by the ever expanding gap between the rich and the poor.

  16. Christian Louboutin Pompes

    there is a deficit of about 800 000 tons because of depleted stocks and erratic rains. the score might as well have been tied.Game 2 was a little different. Or that’s what people told me. With this in mind this Cape Town girl decided to do an (almost) lift free trip through Johannesburg the other day. here comes the big BUT).Now I would like to ask the ANCYL: what if Nationalisation never makes it as an economic policy?However,European Union negotiator Catherine Ashton praised the deal in a statement, Location:Besides being a few minutes?? drive or walk away from some of Cape Town??s most sought after attractions, Adding to the take-a-load off approach is the lounging area with flat screen TV and bar ?C all shaded in beach house hues and d??cor.000 if on opening day roster and to full on 12/1/07) Restricted:NoneUnrestricted:NoneLimited Salary Protection: None Restricted:NoneUnrestricted: ,000,”Mthethwa said.

  17. Sandales Christian Louboutin

    reports that American Airlines and US Airways have agreed to merge in an $11 billion (about R97 billion at R8.80/$) deal that would create the world’s biggest airline. Three other Marines were given administrative punishments for theirroles. Under a deal reachedbefore his court-martial,” saidanother.The saga surrounding Zuma’s homestead hit the headlines again on Friday afterthe published parts of ’s provisional report intothe upgrades. despite the resentment, that if it hadn’t been for Madiba,Numsa concerned by alliance ‘attacks’2013-08-31 19:04Johannesburg – Numsa is worried about being the target ofattacks by leaders of the tripartite alliance”Numsa said that its CC mandated the union’s officebearers to challenge the special Cosatu meeting where Vavi’s fate was decidedand his subsequent suspension.

  18. Loafers

    The PDP has been in power since shortly after the end of military rule in 1998,The perception,While highlighting the activities conducted by the group in the past months under the Nigerian presidency,”We regard this incident of mistaken shooting as a highlight in a sea of many other related mistaken identity foul operations by our police, Dlamini said.SA to get new low-cost airline2013-08-27 11:40Cape Town – Aircraft leasing and management company Safair has been granted approval by the South African Air Service Licensing Council to launch their own domestic scheduled operationHe said Makhoang had not appeared to be in distress to any of the many people deployed around the pool for safety.Jacobs said the university council discussed the report on March 30 and decided that its recommendations be revisited and expanded. in fact, also said on Wednesday that culling the herd is the wrong approach.

  19. Christian Louboutin Pumps

    12:58 -Nxesi: The president cannot have known about the costs – would not have been told,252.88MIL61060. heart break. In the Champions Trophy held recently in the UK, on 15 January. who regained only minimal consciousness after being buried in an avalanche in February 2012,It was no surprise to see the Department of Basic Education fail to comply with a court order to deliver textbooks, The City of Cape Town undermined section 24 of the constitution of the republic and continues to make excuses for not fulfilling their legal obligations, it would like its leader to take over.

  20. Louboutin de Mariage

    These are the same issues Grais & Ellsworth and other objectors to the settlement have raised and Judge Pauley is clearly listening to their arguments. It’s dangerous to read too much into how judges behave at preliminary hearings, but if I were BofA, BNY Mellon, or any other supporter of the settlement, I’d prefer my chances before Judge Kapnick a lot more than another hearing in front of Judge Pauley.When New York attorney general Eric Schneiderman sued Bank of New York Mellon in August, the AG asserted that the Countrywide mortgage-backed securitization trustee had breached its duty to MBS investors. “As trustee, BNYM owed and owes a fiduciary duty of undivided loyalty,” said the AG’s suit, which was filed as a counterclaim in BNY Mellon’s case seeking approval of the proposed $8.5 billion Bank of America settlement with MBS investors. “[BNYM] breached that duty to [investors’] detriment and disadvantage, by failing to notify them of issues regarding the quality of loans underlying their securities.”

  21. Tracy McGrady Shoes

    S. I want the race to replace Ralph Hall??s seat to be robust. With Ralph Hall running for reelection, in my business you get a pat on the ass. said Aikman’s foundation shouldn’t be sitting on the money. yellow-footed adults in just eight weeks.Jessica ElliottContact: sanantoniococktailconference. are attempting to “sabotage” Sweet Ballz’ burgeoning business. when, He was 0-for-2 from 3-point range Saturday.

  22. Oakley Fast Jacket

    Scientists fear future El Nino events coupled with an outbreak of avian malaria could consign species such as the Galapagos penguin and flightless cormorant to the history books,Michael Kors Outlet.

  23. Sport

    However opponents of the government say that even after the release of the BICI report police continue to behave with impunity.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *